I just really think that the plots are not well thaught out and that Meyer simply just cant write ( has anyone else notised that she tries to use big word but they dont end up making any sence( its actually rather funny)
I know that ill probably get like hazed for saying this but does any one agree?
Personally I'm a huge re-reader. Because I read very fast, I tend to devour books as soon I get my hot little hands on them. The second or third read through is almost always better, and I get a lot more out of a book that way. That said, I have never read an entire book more than... 5 times? I think? Though there are certain parts of books that are like favorite songs, and when I'm in a certain mood I'll open up the book and read those chapters.
Haven't read Twilight at all, so I can't really state an opinion on that part...
i haven't read twilight(read the jacket and a few pages in a book store and just didn't feel it). but my brother and his girlfriend read it and said it was quite possibly one of the stupidest books they'd ever read for all the reasons stated above.
I think the comparison to HP is in the popularity, not the content. Like HP these books have crossed over into adult popularity. For people from the HP generation this may not seem like much, but it really is quite a feat. I agree that the book really have NOTHING in common except for their mass appeal.