Nerdfighters

which, out of these two amazing series is the best there can only be 1

Views: 634

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I'm not a devoted Harry Potterverse fan, but on all accounts Harry Potter wins.

On writing (dismal, but got better with every book). On Plot. On role models.
Twilight is a horribly written "book," if you can call it that.
So I have to go with Harry Potter. Because Harry's not a Mary Sue. XD
I'm gonna go with Harry Potter. Mostly, because as Stephen King put it, the only difference between JK Rowling and Stephenie Meyer, is that Rowling can write. My english teacher also agrees with me on this one.
Oh.

My.

Goodness.

THIS IS NOT A QUESTION. PLEASE, NO.

Harry Potter.

kthxbye.
i am a really huge twilight fan.

but it doesn't even come close to harry potter.
harry potter appeals to everyone, is written better, has better plot lines, has more relatable characters, and is just a better series in general.
Harry Potter by far. I read the first Twilight and I thought it was pretty good, and then I tried to read the second but couldn't. I just couldn't stand half of every single page talking about how good Edward smelled.
potter
Are you kidding me?! Don't make me go off on a rant. Harry Potter, hands down.
Harry Potter. No question.

Mostly because if you took out what made the story unique (HP: Wizard School, Twilight: Vampires) Then you'd have a sort of "homeless to Harvard" tale with Harry Potter, but with Twilight you'd have a love story about a pathetic girl and her abusive boyfriend.
Harry potter
Harry potter now doubt.

its way better written, it has way more-well rounded characters.

and it doesn't feed girls this perpetual lie that all love is perfect and a girl should get married and raise a familiy. Because I know that after Breaking Dawn, the dreams of girls around me reading it went from Docter to stay-at-home mom with a dream wedding.
HARRY FTW

RSS

© 2013   Created by Hank Green.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service