Katherines or Alaska?

[Tristan]

If you had to pick (both are great books) but if you had to pick a favourite between the two, which would it be?
Mine would def. be Katherines as I find myself relating to it more.
What say you?

[Chip, A Former Ningmaster]

Alaska, no question. AoK is good but it just can't match the amazingness of LfA

[Shawn]

ALASKA FTW!!!!! Sorry for the outbust. but LfA was definitely my favorite. I LOVED AoK, but I agree with chip. Alaska is just too amazing.

[David]

I'm not going to pick. I think the two are like the old Kirk vs. Picard debate. Alaska is a book about characters (TOS) and Katherines is about plot (TNG). They're both great books, but they're great for different reasons.

And besides, everyone knows that Paper Towns/Sisko pwns all other books/captains.

[Tristan]

hehe. That's true it really is a Kirk/Picard type thing. lol

[Chip, A Former Ningmaster]

But but but Picard is so much better than Kirk! XD

[MMK]

agree Picard is way better (also Patrick Stewart is better than William Shatner)

[RubyRogue]

agreed

[Chip, A Former Ningmaster]

But but but but Picard so completely owns Kirk! Can't really speak for any of the other captains...

[Rachel]

I am in love with them both but I have to say Katherines

I love Alaska, but I enjoyed Katherines more. :D

[MMK]

I definatly agree. I think I understand Colin a little better.

[Flyyn duMartier]

Katherines was hilarious and I loved the Theorum, but I LOVED Alaska. It was so much more thoughtful and poignant.

[Katie the tree hugger]

Looking for Alaska.
I annotated Alaska and I never do that with books that aren't for school. There was just so many things I wanted to be able to look back at again.