I live there too (I'm in Newburgh)!!! And I know absolutely zero nerdfighters in this area until now, even though I've been trying to recruit them via my job at the library and a plan involving a bunch of sticky notes expertly placed in all of the John Green books.
I've told some friends about Nerdfighteria... only one, my best friend, has really gotten into it, but the rest at least humor me. But besides the people I've told about it, I don't know of any Nerdfighters in my area.
I'm living in Austria, guess there are like 3 nerdfighters in this whole country!? Although on my first day on the forums here I met a fellow Austrian nerdfighter, that was pretty amazing, I mean - what are the odds? :D
I live in Wisconsin, and there's one other Nerdfighter in my town, besides my mother and sister. I don't know her at all, though. I try to tell my friends, but they don't get it. They'd all much rather be playing football or basketball than reading or thinking deeply. I'm looking for more people around here, too.