Note: If you haven't read the books, you shouldn't be here. And you shouldn't be on this website, or on the internet, or in the world, really. Go read them. Now!

We see a lot of deaths in the books, the major ones starting with Goblet of Fire, I think. (Or was there an important one before that? Can't remember.)

So, yeah, which death troubled you the most? If you can't decide, think in terms of volume of tears cried. Or number of hair strands pulled out in grief.

Tags: death

Views: 1658

Replies to This Discussion

Fred, definitely. Dobby is a close second.

Sirius Black, hands down. Or Fred. I burst into tears in the theater when Fred died.

im going to say sirius with tonks and dobby tied for second

Dobbys death was the saddest.

I think Fred and Serius's death were both extremely sad :(

Snape. I cried so much when he died in the books...

Sirius, without a doubt :( That shattered my soulllll. Next to the Weasleys he was the closest thing to a real family Harry ever had, and he was like a direct link to James, and could tell Harry stories about him and whatnot :( Also, it's just so damn hard not knowing what's behind that veil!!

It wasnt as sad in the movie (well I hate the movie so)

Dobby or Fred. I've read that book 9 almost 10 times now and I still cannot read those two scenes without balling my eyes out and looking like I just lost a family member (which I kind of did).

Yeah, I understand why she killed off a Weasley- if they had all survived it wouldn't work- but I was aiming for Percy. Especially because if it was right after he turned "good" again it would have been really emotional for everyone.

I know! After Fred's death, she wrote that he could never conjure a patronus.

Yeah, that was probably one of the hardest things for me to wrap my mind around. Granted, when he died I threw my book and screamed I was crying so hard.


Youtube Links!

Here are some YT links to channels related to Nerdfighteria and educational content!

*Can you think of any more? Pass along any suggestions to an Admin who will then add it to this list should it fit!

© 2015   Created by Hank Green.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service