Just a group for those who love (and love to discuss) Doctor Who!
Latest Activity: 33 minutes ago
Started by Amanda Cathey. Last reply by Salena 17 hours ago.
Started by Vayda Nicholls. Last reply by Scout Nov 23.
Started by Kelly Norton. Last reply by Jonathon Dean Nov 18.
Got to say, I agree with jonathon on both points, if the articles referenced different sources that might be one thing, but they are all quoting the same source, whose reliability is unknown, that's not news, that's spreading rumours.
And yeah, you can't call it the 50th aniverserary special if nothing portraying to the classic series is featured, which might be heard, most of the surviving actors are looking very different then when they starred in the roll, tough that hasn't stopped them before. Heh, I trust moffat (certainly more then I would have RTD)
What, your sources? BleedingCool isn't that reliable a site - hell, they're the main people reporting the most insanely massive version of the omnirumour that you don't believe... They're not an official source at all.But yes, if it just celebrates NuWho, there is utterly no point in the 50th existing. It simply would be an 8th anniversary special at most.
Seriously, Jonathon? Sounds like someone woke up on the wrong side of the Tardis and needs to sleep a bit longer.
As I said, rumours, but nothing else. Consideringyou just linked to three articles which reported the Bleedingcool story (itself not a totally reliable source), that's still the stage we're at.Frankly, if the classic Doctors do not make an appearance, in the flesh, not culled from archive footage, then no matter what the rest of the special does, it has been an utter waste of time.
Awesome! Still not sure what I'm doing for the 50th, but I am going to cosplay as Hurt's doctor.
GAH THAT IS AMAZING! im going to a party to watch and we are all going to cosplay... and isnt it amazing that after 50 years of the same show we are all still fans and love the old actors as much as the new ones? i think that is rare in many fandoms.
slow clap for emily
also i never heard 8 was going to be in it untill now . whats the sorce? he is the only doctor i havnt watched yet.
Jonathon: It's McGann, Hurt, Tennant, and Smith. Sorry, hope gone. But it'll be a bit more Hurt than Tennant or Smith, but they're still there.
And I'm not excited for Tennant or Smith, but you have to be excited for McGann and Hurt! That's why I'm watching it.
Anthony- I'm ignoring you despite being an avid reader/writer and huge Whovian. The other discussion about the 50th is way more interesting. Let me explain why...
In your comment you started with "If you don't know what a script is." I found this condescending because anyone capable of writing beautifully enough to help you would surely be aware of the types of literature that people currently create. I was uninspired by the name Charlotte Smith because we've had Sarah Jane Smith and Mickey Smith already. There is no way your character is going to be better than those two. You said both, "her [Charlotte's] personality is like Rose and Donna, she is chubby, smart and funny," and, "His personality is like 9th, 10th and 11th." My issue with that is 9, 10, and 11 are entirely different and so are Rose and Donna. Plus if you are creating something original you don't want to try to emulate what has already been done because you will fail. I could take inspiration from the previous 11 doctors, but because you are a different actor the outcome would be terrible. You want your companion and your Doctor to be unique. My final complaint is that you said, "She is also sad sometimes." I don't know anyone who isn't sad sometimes. I don't know anyone who never cries. Emotions are not character traits they are states of being every human passes through.
That's why I'm not interested in helping you. If you are willing to change those things then we can talk.
Sign Upor Sign In
Here are some links to help spread the awesome:
© 2013 Created by Hank Green.
Report an Issue |
Terms of Service
Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator.